ToFD depth resolution against depth

Differentiating the ToFD depth relation shows how much arrival-time change a millimetre of depth actually produces: dt/dd = 2*d / (c*sqrt(S^2 + d^2)). Inverting it gives the depth uncertainty produced by a timing uncertainty, delta_d = delta_t * c * sqrt(S^2 + d^2) / (2*d).

The gradient goes to zero at the scanning surface, so near-surface depth uncertainty is unbounded: at a 70 mm PCS a diffractor at 1 mm and one at 3 mm differ by under 40 nanoseconds of arrival time. Deep in the wall the gradient tends to 2/c and the uncertainty tends to delta_t*c/2, which for steel and a 20 nanosecond timing uncertainty is about 0.06 mm. This asymmetry is why ToFD sizes mid-wall and lower-wall flaws far better than shallow ones, and why through-wall height of a deep flaw is more trustworthy than the absolute depth of a shallow one.

The timing uncertainty to enter is not only the digitiser step. It combines the digitisation interval, the operator repeatability in placing a cursor on a diffracted signal (typically a fraction of a cycle), and any jitter in the trigger. Using one digitisation interval alone gives an optimistic answer.

This figure is only the timing contribution. Errors in the PCS, in the assumed velocity, in probe alignment and in flaw position off the centreline all add to it, and near the surface the PCS term normally dominates. Quote depth accuracy from measurements on a reference block containing targets at known depths, and use this calculation to understand where the errors come from.

Timing uncertainty is not the only clock-related limit. The transmitted pulse has a finite duration tau = n_cycles/f, and two diffracted signals closer in time than that duration merge into one. Feeding tau through the same gradient gives the minimum resolvable separation of two tips at a given depth, h_min = tau*c*sqrt(S^2 + d^2)/(2*d). With a 70 mm PCS and a well damped two-cycle 5 MHz pulse that is about 3.6 mm at 12 mm depth: a flaw of smaller through-wall height there shows a single merged signal and cannot be sized from its tips at all, however fine the digitiser.

Compression wave

Worked example

Probe centre separation70 mm
Depth of interest12 mm
Timing uncertainty0.02 µs
Compression velocity5900 m/s
Probe centre frequency5 MHz
Cycles in the pulse2
Half separation35 mm
Half sound path at that depth37 mm
Time gradient dt/dd0.1099
Depth uncertainty0.182 mm
Uncertainty as percent of depth1.52 %
Pulse duration0.4 µs
Minimum resolvable tip separation3.64 mm

S = 35 mm and c = 5.9 mm/us. R = sqrt(35^2 + 12^2) = sqrt(1225 + 144) = sqrt(1369) = 37.00 mm exactly. Gradient = 2 x 12 / (5.9 x 37) = 24 / 218.3 = 0.10994 us/mm, so 0.1099 to 4 dp. Depth uncertainty = 0.02 x 5.9 x 37 / 24 = 4.366 / 24 = 0.18192 mm, that is 0.182 mm, which is 100 x 0.18192 / 12 = 1.5160 percent, so 1.52 percent. Pulse-limited two-tip resolution: tau = 2/5 = 0.400 us, so h_min = 0.400 x 5.9 x 37 / (2 x 12) = 87.32 / 24 = 3.6383 mm, that is 3.64 mm — a flaw of smaller height at 12 mm depth shows one merged tip signal.

Use at your own risk — verify before you act

These calculators support, and never replace, the judgement of qualified NDT and engineering personnel. Results are provided as is, without warranty of any kind, express or implied, and must be independently verified against the governing code edition named in your contract before being used in any inspection, acceptance, rejection, radiation-safety or fitness-for-service decision. By using them you accept full responsibility for how the results are applied; NDT Inspect, its owners and contributors accept no liability for any loss, damage, injury or death arising from their use or from reliance on them. If a result matters to safety, check it by hand and have it reviewed by a competent person.

Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.