Thickness grid statistics and projection

A single thickness reading is a sample, not a measurement of a component. Surface roughness, probe placement, couplant thickness, local pitting and the operator’s hand all move the number, and the spread between readings at one location is usually larger than the metal lost between two inspections. Taking a small grid — four quadrant points, or a 3 × 3 pattern over a corroded patch — and treating the set statistically is what turns readings into data.

The minimum is what most codes want, because pressure retention is governed by the thinnest section, and API 510 and 570 both work from minimum measured thickness at a condition monitoring location. The mean is more stable and is what a corrosion rate should be trended on where the loss is genuinely general, while the standard deviation and the range are the honest statement of how repeatable the location is. A grid whose spread is several tenths of a millimetre cannot resolve a 0.05 mm/yr corrosion rate over a five-year interval, no matter how many decimal places the gauge displays.

Projecting forward is a straight subtraction: multiply the corrosion rate by the years ahead and take it off the wall. Doing it from the minimum gives the conservative answer used for scheduling; doing it from the mean gives the general-thinning answer; and the mean less two standard deviations is a useful indicator of where the thinnest point of the grid is likely to sit if the pattern continues.

Keep the grid pattern and its reference marks identical between inspections. Readings taken from a re-drawn grid are a different sample, and a change of a few tenths between them is more likely to be relocation than corrosion.

Compression wave

Worked example

Reading 112.1 mm
Reading 211.8 mm
Reading 312.4 mm
Reading 411.5 mm
Reading 512 mm
Reading 611.9 mm
Reading 712.3 mm
Reading 811.6 mm
Corrosion rate0.15 mm/yr
Years ahead to project5 years
Readings used8
Minimum reading11.5 mm
Maximum reading12.4 mm
Mean thickness11.95 mm
Range (max − min)0.9 mm
Standard deviation0.316 mm
Mean less two standard deviations11.32 mm
Projected minimum thickness10.75 mm
Projected mean thickness11.2 mm

Eight readings summing to 95.60 mm give a mean of 11.95 mm; the extremes are 11.50 and 12.40 mm, a 0.90 mm range. The squared deviations total 0.700 mm², so the sample variance is 0.700/7 = 0.100 and s = 0.316 mm — meaning a 0.15 mm/yr rate needs at least a couple of years between inspections to rise above the scatter. Projecting five years at 0.15 mm/yr removes 0.75 mm: minimum 10.75 mm, mean 11.20 mm.

Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.