Coil shot current, intermediate fill factor

The two familiar coil formulas sit at the ends of a range. NI = 35 000/((L/D)+2) applies when the coil bore area is less than twice the part area (high fill), and NI = 45 000/(L/D) when it is at least ten times the part area (low fill). Most real coil shots land somewhere between those two, and the standards close the gap with a straight-line interpolation on the area ratio Y = coil bore area / part cross-sectional area.

Physically the interpolation reflects how far the part sits from the windings. Close in, the flux is dense and few ampere-turns are needed. Far out, the flux has spread across the bore and more magnetomotive force is required to reach the same field in the part. At Y = 2 the formula returns exactly the high fill answer; at Y = 10 it returns exactly the low fill answer.

The length-to-diameter ratio still governs the demagnetising field from the part’s own end poles, so L/D enters through both endpoint formulas and remains restricted to the 2 to 15 band. For a round part in a round coil, Y is simply the square of the diameter ratio; for anything else, compare true cross-sectional areas and use the greatest cross-sectional diagonal as D.

Interpolated ampere-turns carry the same ±10% tolerance as the endpoint formulas and the same obligation to prove field adequacy on the part itself with a Hall-effect probe or an artificial flaw shim.

Worked example

Part length250 mm
Part diameter50 mm
Coil bore diameter100 mm
Coil turns5
L/D used5
Fill area ratio Y4
Ampere-turns at low fill limit9000 A-turn
Ampere-turns at high fill limit5000 A-turn
Required ampere-turns6000 A-turn
Ampere-turns, -10%5400 A-turn
Ampere-turns, +10%6600 A-turn
Coil current1200 A
Current, lower tolerance1080 A
Current, upper tolerance1320 A
Coil positions needed1

A 250 mm x 50 mm bar in a 100 mm bore coil. L/D = 250/50 = 5. Y = (100/50)² = 4, inside the 2 to 10 interpolation band. Endpoints: NI(low fill) = 45 000/5 = 9 000; NI(high fill) = 35 000/(5+2) = 5 000. Interpolating: NI = [5 000 x (10-4) + 9 000 x (4-2)]/8 = [30 000 + 18 000]/8 = 6 000 ampere-turns. Over 5 turns that is 1 200 A, with a ±10% band of 1 080 to 1 320 A. The 250 mm part fits inside one coil position.

Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.